Skip to main content
UOIT Home
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/10155/1191

Issue Date:  8
Title: The impact of individual differences on the interviewing success and post-training performance of investigative interviewers
Authors: Akca, Davut
Degree : Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)
Department : Forensic Psychology
Supervisor : Eastwood, Joseph
Keywords: Investigative interviewing
Aptitudes
Big Five
Interview performance
Training efficacy
Abstract: In this thesis, whether and how personality characteristics affect the performance in investigative interviewing and the efficacy of training was examined in a three-step research design. In Study 1, the structure of a 50-item aptitudes scale, a modified and extended version of the Police Interviewing Competences Inventory (PICI), was assessed using a general population sample (N = 300), and a four-dimensional aptitudes scale was created. The four dimensions found were named as Humane (13 items), Communicative-Insisting (13 items), Self-controlled (9 items), and Careful-Tenacious (10 items). In Study 2, student participants (N = 154) completed the aptitudes and the Five Factor Model (FFM) scales, and then interviewed witnesses who watched a mock robbery crime video. Interviewer performance was assessed based on the amount of details they could elicit, the perception of the witness, and researcher ratings of behaviours and question usage. Three dimensions of the FFM were correlated with the success measures: Agreeableness with witness perception and appropriate questioning, Extraversion with researcher ratings and inappropriate questioning, and Openness with researcher ratings. Only the Communicative-Insisting dimension of the aptitudes scale predicted high researcher ratings. In Study 3, we used a policing student sample (N = 38) to investigate the impact of training on the interview performance and also to analyze how training effect interacts with personality measures when predicting the performance of participants. Overall, training increased the performance of participants in most of the success measures. The Humane dimension of the aptitudes scale and the Openness/Intellect dimension of the FFM predicted training efficacy. The post-interview performance of the participants was predicted by the Openness/Intellect, Agreeableness, Extraversion, and Neuroticism (negatively) dimensions of the Big Five and the Careful-Tenacious and Communicative-Insisting dimensions of the aptitudes scale. Findings might help police departments to identify potential successful interviewers and develop new training policies.
Appears in Collections:Electronic Theses and Dissertations (Public)
Faculty of Social Science and Humanities - Doctoral Dissertations

Files in This Item:

File Description SizeFormat
Akca_Davut.pdf1.01 MBAdobe PDFView/Open

Items in e-scholar@UOIT are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.